Mutual fund manager performance does not persist and the return of stock picking is zero.
Mutual fund manager performance does not persist and the return of stock picking is zero.

Mutual fund manager performance does not persist and the return of stock picking is zero.

William J. Bernstein

The quote “Mutual fund manager performance does not persist and the return of stock picking is zero” suggests that over time, the ability of mutual fund managers to consistently outperform the market through active stock selection is largely illusory. In simpler terms, while some fund managers may do well in a given year or over a short period, their success does not reliably continue into the future. This observation implies that beating market averages through skillful investment choices is extremely difficult, if not impossible.

### Explanation

1. **Market Efficiency**: The statement aligns with the Efficient Market Hypothesis (EMH), which posits that financial markets are “informationally efficient.” This means all available information about stocks is already reflected in their prices. Therefore, any advantage gained from analyzing and selecting stocks should be fleeting because new information gets quickly absorbed into prices.

2. **Randomness and Luck**: Many times, a manager’s outperformance can be attributed to luck rather than skill. Just as one might flip a coin and get heads several times in a row by chance alone, mutual funds can experience temporary successes without demonstrating genuine investment acumen.

3. **Costs of Active Management**: Actively managed funds often have higher fees than index funds due to management expenses related to research and trading activities. These costs reduce net returns for investors and make it even harder for active managers to outperform benchmarks after accounting for fees.

### Implications Today

In today’s world, this idea has significant implications:

1. **Investment Strategy**: For individual investors considering where to allocate their money, this insight suggests they might be better off investing in low-cost index funds rather than actively managed mutual funds—a strategy that’s been increasingly popular due to its historical outperformance when adjusted for costs.

2. **Risk Assessment**: Investors need to understand their risk tolerance better; chasing high-performing managers may lead them down an unpredictable path with potentially disappointing results over time.

3. **Behavioral Finance Awareness**: Knowing that performance doesn’t persist helps counteract biases such as hindsight bias (believing past successful strategies will continue) or anchoring (sticking with previously successful investments).

### Application in Personal Development

The principle behind this quote can also extend beyond finance into personal development:

1. **Skill Building Over Time**: Just as success in investing isn’t just about making one good pick but developing sustainable long-term strategies based on consistent practices—such as learning continuously or honing specific skills—personal growth often requires sustained effort instead of searching for quick wins.

2. **Embrace Learning from Failure**: Accepting that not every attempt will yield success allows individuals to learn from failures rather than being discouraged by them; much like how fund performance fluctuates without guarantee of future results—individuals should focus on building resilience through learning experiences rather than fixating on singular successes or setbacks.

3. **Long-Term Perspective vs Short-Term Gains**: Emphasizing patience and persistence aligns with long-term growth principles where immediate rewards are less important compared to steady progress towards life goals—akin to remaining invested during market fluctuations instead of attempting frequent trades based on momentary trends.

In summary, recognizing that stock-picking prowess doesn’t translate into lasting performance encourages both investors and individuals focused on personal development alike to adopt more sustainable strategies based on consistent action rather than relying solely on fortuitous outcomes or transient successes.

Created with ❤️ | ©2025 HiveHarbor | Terms & Conditions | Privacy Policy | Disclaimer| Imprint | Opt-out Preferences

 

Log in with your credentials

Forgot your details?